SmartVote: Afghan Training Mission Has High Risk of Casualties, Low Chance of Success

Media Release
For Immediate Release
April 11, 2011

Afghan Training Mission Has High Risk of Casualties, Low Chance of Success

(Ottawa) The government’s plan to extend the Canadian Forces mission in Afghanistan deserves a public debate, argues a new report published by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives and the Rideau Institute.

Analysts Michael Byers and Stuart Webb determine that the new training mission, first proposed by the Liberals then adopted by the Conservatives, poses many dangers to Canadian soldiers:

All military operations carry inherent risks of accidents and “friendly-fire”;

Recruitment and training centres have repeatedly been targeted for attacks by insurgents;

Canadian soldiers may be expected to provide security perimeters around their bases, exposing them to attack;

Training will likely require operations in the field, “outside the wire,” where a training mission could quickly turn into actual combat with insurgents;

And most alarmingly, insurgents have already infiltrated the ranks of recruits for the Afghan National Army, and have turned their guns on foreign military trainers inside training facilities.

The report concludes that despite Prime Minister Harper’s stated intention of ensuring a “safer” mission for the Canadian Forces in Afghanistan, numerous Canadian soldiers will likely be killed or permanently injured, and the mission will ultimately not be successful.

“Although they won’t admit it, most Western governments have already given up on the country,” said co-author Michael Byers. “The training mission is clearly an exit strategy that will cost more Canadians their lives.”

The authors worry that the election has pre-empted a proper public discussion of the mission. “Canadians need to be made aware of the risks of this mission,” added co-author Stewart Webb.

Training Can Be Dangerous: A Realistic Assessment of the Proposed Canadian Mission to Train Afghan National Security Forces, published by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives and the Rideau Institute.

– 30 –

http://www.policyalternatives.ca/publications/reports/training-can-be-dangerous

Michael Byers tel. 604 561-3049, e. michael.byers@ubc.ca

Read More


Leave a Reply




Colombia peace deal shows power of mediation

On August 24, 2016 an historic peace deal was reached between the FARC rebels and the government of Colombia, after four years of secret negotiations. The five-decade-long conflict, rooted in Colombia’s unique land distribution and political exclusion of large segments of the population, has killed at least 220,000 people and displaced millions. Anna Maria Tremonti, host […]

Read More
View the Blog »

Join in global efforts to abolish nuclear weapons

Rideau Institute President Peggy Mason was honoured to speak at the international conference Building a Nuclear-Weapon-Free World  in Astana, Kazakhstan ...

Peter Langille: UN peace operations need Canada’s expertise

  [caption id="attachment_6421" align="aligncenter" width="300"] .[/caption] In light of the Liberal government’s commitment to increase Canada’s participation in UN peacekeeping efforts and ...